Let us confess, a writers’ group has its flaws. One is that most of the people there are not professionals in their field and sometimes the new writer will want advice from people in the business. That is where assorted agencies and companies come in.
One of our group recently got the urge for a bit of ‘pro’ advice, as it were, and especially some proper editing, and so approached a couple of these institutions (we may name them later, after consulting our lawyers, or just out of pig headedness.) Our would-be best seller writer, having a particular style sent along decent chunks of work and asked whom might the sympathetic editor be that would lick the work into shape.
After a few days one agency hadn’t replied, but the other one did. They were enthusiastic. Hurrah! For a whisker under £700 they would be delighted to write a report! (In case overseas readers are wondering, that’s over US$1,000 at today’s exchange rate!)
But wait! Our intrepid author spied a flaw. They weren’t going to actually edit the work, but give a major report on it. Then the author would have to edit it and then, for any further advice, would need to resubmit the manuscript along with another fee (albeit discounted by a whole 5% this time.) Hmmm. And then there was the editor / report writer. He came highly recommended (well, he would), and he’d nearly won awards (which is actually rather good because it meant he’d been published and sold reasonably well) and… well, our author made uses of the services of the good people of Google.
The Google elves unearthed an interview with the editor / report writer in one of those big newspapers favoured by people who think they are arty and read a lot of books (and sometimes buy them too). Good News! Oh wait, what’s this bit about the books he likes to read? Oh dear.
You see, our author writes comedy. People, of many differing types, including some of those regulars at Richmond Writers’ Circle, have actually laughed out loud at our author’s efforts. (And for the right reasons. The material is funny. It isn’t that our author turned up having forgotten the donning of the trousers that morning before leaving the house.) Unfortunately the prospective editor had been variously decsribed as ‘wry’ and ‘charmingly ridiculous’. The words ‘funny’ and ‘comedy’ had not been used.
Now, ‘funny’ and ‘comedy’ are to ‘wry’ and ‘charmingly ridiculous’ as ‘love’ and ‘sex’ are to ‘fondness’ and, well, ‘you know when you really fancy someone and you’ve spent a lovely evening with them and they really seem into you and they invite you back to their place for coffee and… all you get is coffee? Like that.’
You can see our author’s dilemma. But what of the suggested editor’s reading habits? The fingers are as lead as they reach for the keyboard, dear reader, as lead. First of all, apparently he doesn’t like fiction. Furthermore, the little he does read is ‘Money’ by Martin Amis, which he re-reads every year, Brett Easton Ellis, but he doesn’t like the violence (what the hell’s he reading Brett Easton Ellis for then, the jokes?) and The Fountainhead by Ayn Rand. For those of you not familiar with the works of Ms Rand, she was a writer so devoid of humour that she makes Margaret Thatcher look like the understudy for Joan Rivers!
Surely there is someone out there that can edit comedy? Someone that knows about stuff with jokes and actual punch lines. Someone must understand why “A Dragon is for Life, not just Hogswatch Night” is hilarious!
All advice gratefully received. Suicide notes Suggestions on a postcard please.